Read and enjoy the latest about the fascinating world of trademarks here. The latest on developments in the field of trademark rights, including background information, relevant cases and videos about a range of trademark topics can be found in our Thinktank.
Blogs
Chaos in the perfumery
A perfume bottle, besides the fragrance and the brand it holds, is often a work of art in itself. The flasks are often so distinctive that the brand can be recognised by the bottle’s shape. Chanel recently filed an opposition against Romanian perfume brand CHAOS’ application of the 3D shape of their latest fragrance, because of the close resemblance to the Chanel No. 5 bottle.
That’s a real scare!
When choosing a trademark for your products and/or services, you typically go for one that is distinctive and appealing. You aim to go for an attractive trademark, because you want to sell your product or service. However, you could also opt for an ugly one. It doesn’t happen often, but it would certainly be distinctive. Or wouldn’t it be?
Offensive trademarks
Trademarks must not violate public order or principles of morality. Trademarks that are racist, offensive, or unacceptable for any other reason will be refused. This is a broad standard, often shaped by cultural differences. Recently, the Benelux office intervened with the trademark "WHITE ONLY" for a nightclub. Offensive?
"That prompt could have been better" – when ChatGPT defends a case
The use of AI, such as ChatGPT, has become indispensable across various professions. The legal sector is no exception, with AI increasingly making its way into legal proceedings. But is it wise to rely on an AI tool for legal representation? Let’s take a closer look at a case in the Benelux where AI played a role in a trademark opposition procedure.
Municipal logos: plagiarism or pure coincidence?
One moment, a municipality proudly unveils its new logo; the next, it faces accusations of plagiarism. This recently happened to the municipality of Urk in The Netherlands. Their new logo features a stylized "U," outlined and rendered in two shades of blue. Controversy quickly arose, as the design was said to closely resemble the logo of the municipality of Terneuzen—a similarly outlined letter, in this case, a "T," also featuring various shades of blue.
IKEA’s logo proves crucial in infringement proceedings
Everyone knows the IKEA logo: an oval shape surrounding the letters "IKEA" and iconic blue and yellow colour scheme. In January 2024, a Chinese company from Shenzhen filed a trademark application for a logo that looked suspiciously similar to IKEA's. The only difference was that it featured the word ‘IKIKI’ rather than IKEA. Both words begin with IK, but the main similarity concerns the graphic elements, as anyone who sees the Chinese logo would automatically think of IKEA.
Basic Frit: when a name sounds too good to be true
Imagine, just a week after opening a fry shop with a catchy name, you are forced to change its name. This happened to Belgian couple Diony Bickx and Sheila Vergauwen, who playfully named their shop "Basic Frit," a nod to the well-known fitness chain "Basic Fit." The name was meant to create a fun association with pushing oneself to the limit, which one does both in sports and the couple does in their business.
Crocs, Inc. – you either hate them or you love them
Some people wear Crocs as a fashion statement in the city, while others wear them strictly in the privacy of their garden and hide them behind the door the minute they go back inside. The Crocs shoes below aren’t everyone’s thing. However, we are talking about Crocs here − aren’t we? Sufang Yan, a Slovakian company, registered the shoes shown above as a European design in 2022.
Guidance on the assessment of bad faith in trademark applications
While EU trademark law lacks a precise definition of bad faith, recent case law from the European Court of Justice clarified the interpretation. Aiming for consistency across Europe, a new common approach for IP Offices of EU Member States is introduced to address bad faith in trademark applications: Convergence Program 13 or simply CP13.
Nature as a trademark owner
There is a current trend towards granting legal personality to nature. The idea is that this makes it possible to grant nature rights that can be explicitly taken into account when decisions are being made, or even enforced on nature’s behalf. This is already happening in Spain, where the Mar Menor lagoon has acquired legal personality. In the Netherlands, a politician has started lobbying to grant rights to Limburg’s hilly landscape.
Is a major Sato trademark conflict brewing in Japan?
A Japanese economist by the name of Yoshida recently published a calculation showing that subject to certain conditions and assumptions, everyone in Japan will have Sato as their last name by 2531. Why? Well, Japan is the only country in the world where spouses must have the same last name. Yoshida raised the issue − with success − to draw attention to what he considers to be an outdated law.
J’adore
Back in the day, trademark applications in bad faith used to be a common occurrence in China, but this amount seems to have declined by recent more stringent Chinese legislation. Western brands stood for quality and status, and what could be easier than copying such established trademarks? Although it was very clear that the parties weren’t the rightful owners of the copied trademark, this still often happened.
Rubettes’ Trademark Filed "with the Sole Intention to Ruin the Applicant's Existence"
Trademark cases can become deeply personal, and a recent Cancellation action before the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) regarding the ‘Rubettes’ trademark is a striking example of this. The Rubettes are an English pop/glam rock band that achieved significant success with “Sugar Baby Love.” However, their history since then has been marked by conflicts within the band and legal battles. In 1999, Bill Hurd, one of the original founding members, established a separate band using the name “The Rubettes.” This led to litigation in the United Kingdom between him and Alan Williams (lead singer), which was settled in 2002.
Exclusive mirror-design at discounter store Kwantum: allowed?
Kwantum, a Dutch retail chain specializing in home furnishings and decorations known for its affordable prices, introduced a new, furry mirror. The ‘Teddy Wave’ mirror, with its wavy shape and soft frame of teddy-bear fabric, bears a suspicious resemblance to exclusive designer mirrors that costs much, much more. A lyrical client shared the tip on her TikTok account, and the video of the mirror was viewed more than a million times within a day.
Wendy’s snack bar in Zeeland continues to thwart American fast food giant
It sounds like a picaresque novel, a small snack bar in Zeeland hindering a major American fast food chain’s plans to open up in Benelux, but it does show just how important trademark registration can be. If Wendy’s snack bar had not been registered in Benelux, it would never have had the power to exclude American Wendy’s from the region.
Obelix and trademark protection
Obelix, Asterix’s best friend, is one of the main characters in the Asterix comic books. The Asterix & Obelix series is popular all over the world and has been translated into many languages. There is a huge range of Asterix merchandise: mugs, bags and wigs to name a few. There’s even an Asterix theme park in France. We’ll start with a spoiler: the fate of our comic hero Obelix takes a turn for the worse in this blog.
SUPERDRY: not quite so super when it comes to trademark registration
When is a name truly descriptive from a legal standpoint, rendering it ineligible for registration? The British clothing brand SUPERDRY, known for its vintage Americana style with Japanese graphics, recently found out. The European Trademark Office rejected the SUPERDRY trademark for most of the products and services for which the application was filed. The Office ruled that SUPERDRY means 'remarkably free of moisture’ and is descriptive, thus lacking distinctiveness.
The god of travelers and thieves
Exclusive, expensive, coveted. Words that aptly describe the products of the Hermès brand. This fashion house is particularly renowned for its handbags (the Birkin bag being a prime example) and scarves. Luxury goods with a luxurious appeal. It's imperative that the exclusivity and reputation of the brand must be fiercely protected.